Distinct neural mechanisms support inner speaking and inner hearing

authors

• Nalborczyk Ladislas
• Longcamp Marieke
• Bonnard Mireille
• Serveau Victor
• Spieser Laure
• Alario F.-Xavier

keywords

• Inner speech
• Inner speaking
• Inner hearing
• Transcranial magnetic stimulation
• Motor evoked potential
• Cortical excitability
• Inner speech inner speaking inner hearing transcranial magnetic stimulation motor evoked potential cortical excitability
• Inner speech

document type

abstract

Humans have the ability to mentally examine speech. This covert form of speech production is often accompanied by sensory (e.g., auditory) percepts. However, the cognitive and neural mechanisms that generate these percepts are still debated. According to a prominent proposal, inner speech has at least two distinct phenomenological components: inner speaking and inner hearing. We used transcranial magnetic stimulation to test whether these two phenomenologically distinct processes are supported by distinct neural mechanisms. We hypothesised that inner speaking relies more strongly on an online motor-to-sensory simulation that constructs a multisensory experience, whereas inner hearing relies more strongly on a memory-retrieval process, where the multisensory experience is reconstructed from stored motor-to-sensory associations. Accordingly, we predicted that the speech motor system will be involved more strongly during inner speaking than inner hearing. This would be revealed by modulations of TMS evoked responses at muscle level following stimulation of the lip primary motor cortex. Overall, data collected from 31 participants corroborated this prediction, showing that inner speaking increases the excitability of the primary motor cortex more than inner hearing. Moreover, this effect was more pronounced during the inner production of a syllable that strongly recruits the lips (vs. a syllable that recruits the lips to a lesser extent). These results are compatible with models assuming that the primary motor cortex is involved during inner speech and contribute to clarify the neural implementation of the fundamental ability of silently speaking in one’s mind.

more information